Serving Richmond and Surrounding AreasMon–Fri 8am–6pm · Sat 9am–3pm(804) 375-4312info@kitchenandbathsexperts.com
Call Now · (804) 375-4312
Home / Blog / Bathrooms

Bathtub Guide: Choosing the Right Tub for Your Remodel

· 3 min read
Luxury primary bathroom remodel with soaking tub

Many Richmond homeowners remove a tub to make room for a bigger shower, and our walk-in shower vs. tub guide explains when that makes sense. But plenty of families want to keep one: for young children, for soaking after a long day, or because it is the only tub in the house. If you are keeping or adding a tub, here is how Kitchen and Bath Experts helps you choose one.

Tub styles

Alcove tub. Installed between three walls, usually with a shower above. A standard alcove tub is 60 inches long and about 30 to 32 inches wide. - Best for: hall baths, kids' baths and any bathroom that needs a tub-shower combination. - See our kids' and Jack-and-Jill bathroom ideas.

Freestanding tub. A sculptural tub that stands on its own, often in the middle of a primary bath or in front of a window. - Best for: primary baths with enough floor space around the tub for cleaning. - Needs a floor- or wall-mounted tub filler, planned before the floor goes in. - See our primary bathroom ideas.

Drop-in tub. Set into a tiled deck or platform. - Best for: whirlpool or air tubs that need an access panel, and large bathrooms. - The deck gives a place to sit and to set things, but takes up more floor space.

Undermount tub. Like a drop-in, but the deck covers the rim for a cleaner look.

Corner tub. Common in 1990s and 2000s primary baths. Many homeowners replace these with a larger shower, or a freestanding tub.

Soaking, whirlpool or air tub?

  • Soaking tubs are deeper than standard tubs, so water covers your shoulders. Japanese-style soaking tubs are short and very deep.
  • Whirlpool tubs use water jets. They need an access panel and more cleaning to keep the plumbing clean.
  • Air tubs use gentle air bubbles. The lines purge themselves, so they are easier to keep clean than whirlpools.

Materials compared

Acrylic Cast iron Stone resin / solid surface Steel
Weight Light Very heavy Heavy Light
Keeps water warm Good Excellent Excellent Fair
Durability Good; can scratch Excellent; enamel can chip Excellent; repairable Fair; enamel chips
Feel Warm to touch Cold at first, then holds heat Warm, smooth matte Cold, thin

Before you buy: three things to check

  1. Floor support. A cast iron or stone resin tub plus water and a person can weigh many hundreds of pounds. Upstairs bathrooms in older Richmond homes may need the floor framing checked and reinforced. See remodeling an older home.
  2. The water heater. A large soaking tub can use most of a standard water heater tank. Check the tub's capacity against your water heater before you fall in love with a deep tub.
  3. Getting it in. Measure doorways, stair turns and hallways. Some one-piece tubs will not fit up the stairs of an older home.

Tub-shower combinations

If the tub doubles as a shower, choose a tub with a flat bottom and a slip-resistant surface, add a handheld shower and a glass panel or sliding door, and tile the surround to the ceiling. See our shower glass guide and shower fixtures guide.

Frequently asked questions

What is the most popular bathtub? The acrylic alcove tub, because it fits most hall baths and doubles as a shower.

Are freestanding tubs hard to clean around? Leave several inches between the tub and the wall so you can reach behind it.

Should I keep a tub for resale? Most buyers expect at least one tub in the house, especially families. See our remodel before selling guide.

Choose the right tub with us

We will check your floor, plumbing and water heater and help you choose a tub that fits. Everything is included in one fixed price. Schedule a free in-home consultation.

Free In-Home Consultation

Ready to talk about your project? Get a written proposal with design, materials and installation.

Request an Estimate
Free Estimate

Thirty years of kitchens and baths. Yours is next.

Tell us what you want and when you want it. We'll bring the design, the crew, and the schedule.

(804) 375-4312
  • Free in-home estimate
  • Licensed & insured
  • Financing available [client to confirm]